NYC Council Committee on Technology, October 16, 2026 › Hearing README

Who spoke, panel by panel

Oversight - Continuing Discussion about the Risks Posed by Artificial Intelligence. NYC Council Committee on Technology, October 16, 2026, 01:57:28 of video, 248 speaker turns in 6 parts.

The whole hearing

Each bar is one turn, placed at its time in the recording and as long as it lasted. Bands across the top are the parts of the hearing. Hover or tab to a bar for the speaker and first words; click it, or press Enter, to read the turn below. Arrow keys move between turns in time order. Skip to the table of every turn.

Council Members and the Speaker
AI company
Other witnesses
Council staff

Opening statements 00:00:10 to 00:08:54
Panel 1: SpaceXAI, affirmation, testimony and Council questions (Zoom) 00:08:56 to 01:09:35
Panel 2: Devin Kim, former xAI employee, and his counsel (Zoom) 01:09:36 to 01:37:04
Public testimony, panel 1 (in person) 01:37:05 to 01:48:33
Public testimony, panel 2 (Zoom) 01:48:44 to 01:54:45
Closing remarks and adjournment 01:54:53 to 01:57:20

Select a turn to read it here.

Each part: who spoke, and for how long

Talk time is the sum of each speaker's turns in that part, from the turn start and end times, in minutes and seconds. Bars compare speakers within one part. Council Members includes the Speaker and the chair; witnesses includes everyone who testified.

1. Opening statements

00:00:10 to 00:08:54 · 4 turns · 8:39 of talk

Who had the floor: Council Members 8:25 (97%) · Council staff 0:14 (3%)

Talk time by speaker, Opening statements
Speaker	Role	Turns	Talk time	Seconds
Julie Menin	Speaker	2	5:07	307
Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	1	3:18	198
Sergeant-at-Arms	Sergeant-at-Arms	1	0:14	14

2. Panel 1: SpaceXAI, affirmation, testimony and Council questions (Zoom)

00:08:56 to 01:09:35 · 181 turns · 57:20 of talk

Who had the floor: Council Members 30:29 (53%) · Council staff 0:10 (<1%) · Witnesses 26:40 (47%)

Talk time by speaker, Panel 1: SpaceXAI, affirmation, testimony and Council questions (Zoom)
Speaker	Role	Turns	Talk time	Seconds
Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	85	26:40	1600
Julie Menin	Speaker	45	14:00	840
Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	31	8:20	500
Mercedes Narcisse	Council Member	3	2:55	175
Jennifer Gutiérrez	Council Member	7	2:38	158
Virginia Maloney	Council Member	8	2:35	155
Committee Counsel	Committee Counsel	2	0:10	10

3. Panel 2: Devin Kim, former xAI employee, and his counsel (Zoom)

01:09:36 to 01:37:04 · 43 turns · 26:19 of talk

Who had the floor: Council Members 9:31 (36%) · Witnesses 16:48 (64%)

Talk time by speaker, Panel 2: Devin Kim, former xAI employee, and his counsel (Zoom)
Speaker	Role	Turns	Talk time	Seconds
Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	18	10:13	613
Qiaojing Ella Zheng	Witness — counsel to Devin Kim	3	6:35	395
Julie Menin	Speaker	14	6:16	376
Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	8	3:15	195

4. Public testimony, panel 1 (in person)

01:37:05 to 01:48:33 · 8 turns · 10:35 of talk

Who had the floor: Council Members 1:33 (15%) · Witnesses 9:02 (85%)

Talk time by speaker, Public testimony, panel 1 (in person)
Speaker	Role	Turns	Talk time	Seconds
Bryce Rogers	Witness — RAD Collective	1	2:41	161
Megan Lagerquist	Witness — RAD Collective	1	2:26	146
Kalima [surname unknown]	Witness — Demilitarize Brooklyn Navy Yard	1	2:03	123
Steve Kramer	Witness — Get Out the Vote	1	1:53	113
Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	4	1:33	93

5. Public testimony, panel 2 (Zoom)

01:48:44 to 01:54:45 · 10 turns · 5:34 of talk

Who had the floor: Council Members 0:29 (9%) · Council staff 0:02 (1%) · Witnesses 5:02 (90%)

Talk time by speaker, Public testimony, panel 2 (Zoom)
Speaker	Role	Turns	Talk time	Seconds
Ajeet Singh	Witness — public	2	2:19	139
Chowdhury Hasan Mahmud	Witness — public	1	1:39	99
Sophie Cote	Witness — public	1	1:04	64
Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	5	0:29	29
Sergeant-at-Arms	Sergeant-at-Arms	1	0:02	2

6. Closing remarks and adjournment

01:54:53 to 01:57:20 · 2 turns · 2:26 of talk

Who had the floor: Council Members 2:26 (100%)

Talk time by speaker, Closing remarks and adjournment
Speaker	Role	Turns	Talk time	Seconds
Julie Menin	Speaker	1	2:05	125
Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	1	0:21	21

Every turn as a table (248 rows)

Every speaker turn in time order. Part numbers match the bands and the sections below.
Turn	Start	End	Seconds	Speaker	Role	Part
0	00:00:10	00:00:24	14	Sergeant-at-Arms	Sergeant-at-Arms	1
1	00:00:28	00:05:25	297	Julie Menin	Speaker	1
2	00:05:26	00:08:43	198	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	1
3	00:08:44	00:08:54	10	Julie Menin	Speaker	1
4	00:08:56	00:09:05	9	Committee Counsel	Committee Counsel	2
5	00:09:06	00:09:06	1	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
6	00:09:07	00:09:09	2	Committee Counsel	Committee Counsel	2
7	00:09:11	00:12:49	218	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
8	00:12:50	00:13:17	27	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
9	00:13:20	00:13:50	29	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
10	00:13:51	00:13:59	8	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
11	00:14:02	00:14:27	25	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
12	00:14:28	00:14:48	20	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
13	00:14:49	00:15:04	15	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
14	00:15:04	00:15:27	23	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
15	00:15:28	00:15:30	2	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
16	00:15:30	00:15:50	20	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
17	00:15:51	00:16:04	13	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
18	00:16:04	00:16:15	11	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
19	00:16:17	00:16:21	4	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
20	00:16:22	00:16:31	9	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
21	00:16:33	00:16:59	26	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
22	00:16:59	00:17:36	37	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
23	00:17:37	00:18:12	35	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
24	00:18:12	00:18:54	42	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
25	00:18:56	00:19:16	19	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
26	00:19:18	00:19:25	7	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
27	00:19:26	00:19:40	14	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
28	00:19:40	00:19:45	6	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
29	00:19:46	00:20:00	14	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
30	00:20:04	00:20:20	16	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
31	00:20:21	00:20:46	25	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
32	00:20:46	00:20:55	9	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
33	00:20:56	00:21:09	13	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
34	00:21:09	00:21:29	20	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
35	00:21:30	00:21:55	25	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
36	00:21:57	00:22:19	21	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
37	00:22:19	00:22:56	37	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
38	00:22:56	00:23:02	6	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
39	00:23:03	00:23:15	12	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
40	00:23:16	00:23:34	18	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
41	00:23:35	00:23:37	2	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
42	00:23:37	00:23:50	13	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
43	00:23:52	00:24:09	18	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
44	00:24:10	00:24:21	11	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
45	00:24:22	00:24:30	8	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
46	00:24:32	00:24:35	4	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
47	00:24:38	00:24:43	5	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
48	00:24:43	00:25:38	54	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
49	00:25:41	00:25:50	9	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
50	00:25:50	00:26:13	23	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
51	00:26:13	00:26:26	13	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
52	00:26:26	00:26:41	15	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
53	00:26:42	00:26:57	14	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
54	00:26:57	00:27:10	14	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
55	00:27:11	00:27:13	2	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
56	00:27:15	00:27:21	7	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
57	00:27:23	00:27:28	6	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
58	00:27:29	00:27:46	17	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
59	00:27:47	00:27:55	8	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
60	00:27:56	00:28:04	8	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
61	00:28:04	00:28:16	11	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
62	00:28:17	00:28:19	2	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
63	00:28:20	00:28:29	9	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
64	00:28:30	00:28:39	9	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
65	00:28:40	00:29:09	30	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
66	00:29:10	00:29:17	7	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
67	00:29:17	00:29:39	23	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
68	00:29:42	00:30:19	38	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
69	00:30:20	00:30:24	4	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
70	00:30:25	00:30:37	12	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
71	00:30:38	00:30:41	3	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
72	00:30:42	00:30:57	14	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
73	00:30:57	00:31:04	7	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
74	00:31:05	00:31:42	38	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
75	00:31:42	00:31:47	5	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
76	00:31:49	00:31:56	6	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
77	00:31:56	00:31:58	2	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
78	00:32:00	00:32:09	9	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
79	00:32:09	00:32:13	4	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
80	00:32:14	00:32:24	10	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
81	00:32:24	00:32:42	18	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
82	00:32:43	00:33:22	39	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
83	00:33:22	00:33:39	17	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
84	00:33:40	00:33:43	3	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
85	00:33:44	00:33:48	5	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
86	00:33:49	00:34:56	67	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
87	00:34:57	00:35:01	4	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
88	00:35:02	00:35:04	2	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
89	00:35:06	00:35:18	12	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
90	00:35:18	00:35:33	15	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
91	00:35:33	00:35:39	5	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
92	00:35:41	00:35:46	5	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
93	00:35:46	00:35:59	14	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
94	00:36:00	00:36:06	6	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
95	00:36:07	00:36:13	6	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
96	00:36:14	00:36:42	29	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
97	00:36:43	00:37:15	32	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
98	00:37:15	00:37:39	24	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
99	00:37:40	00:37:52	12	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
100	00:37:53	00:37:57	3	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
101	00:37:58	00:38:13	15	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
102	00:38:13	00:38:37	24	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
103	00:38:37	00:39:14	36	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
104	00:39:15	00:39:30	16	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
105	00:39:32	00:40:12	40	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
106	00:40:15	00:40:41	26	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
107	00:40:44	00:41:05	21	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
108	00:41:06	00:41:26	20	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
109	00:41:27	00:41:50	23	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
110	00:41:51	00:41:59	8	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
111	00:42:00	00:42:45	45	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
112	00:42:46	00:43:02	16	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
113	00:43:03	00:43:12	9	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
114	00:43:13	00:43:50	37	Virginia Maloney	Council Member	2
115	00:43:52	00:44:10	18	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
116	00:44:11	00:44:23	11	Virginia Maloney	Council Member	2
117	00:44:24	00:45:08	44	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
118	00:45:08	00:45:14	5	Virginia Maloney	Council Member	2
119	00:45:15	00:45:19	5	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
120	00:45:20	00:45:32	12	Virginia Maloney	Council Member	2
121	00:45:34	00:45:50	17	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
122	00:45:51	00:46:31	40	Virginia Maloney	Council Member	2
123	00:46:37	00:46:42	5	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
124	00:46:42	00:47:24	41	Virginia Maloney	Council Member	2
125	00:47:25	00:47:58	33	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
126	00:47:58	00:48:03	5	Virginia Maloney	Council Member	2
127	00:48:03	00:48:13	10	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
128	00:48:14	00:48:17	3	Virginia Maloney	Council Member	2
129	00:48:18	00:48:24	5	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
130	00:48:25	00:49:44	79	Mercedes Narcisse	Council Member	2
131	00:49:46	00:50:30	44	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
132	00:50:33	00:50:56	23	Mercedes Narcisse	Council Member	2
133	00:50:57	00:51:45	48	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
134	00:51:46	00:52:59	73	Mercedes Narcisse	Council Member	2
135	00:53:00	00:53:02	2	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
136	00:53:02	00:54:00	58	Jennifer Gutiérrez	Council Member	2
137	00:54:01	00:54:08	7	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
138	00:54:08	00:54:23	14	Jennifer Gutiérrez	Council Member	2
139	00:54:24	00:54:35	11	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
140	00:54:36	00:55:25	49	Jennifer Gutiérrez	Council Member	2
141	00:55:26	00:55:43	17	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
142	00:55:44	00:55:49	5	Jennifer Gutiérrez	Council Member	2
143	00:55:50	00:56:43	53	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
144	00:56:44	00:57:12	28	Jennifer Gutiérrez	Council Member	2
145	00:57:13	00:57:34	21	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
146	00:57:35	00:57:36	2	Jennifer Gutiérrez	Council Member	2
147	00:57:37	00:57:39	2	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
148	00:57:44	00:57:45	1	Jennifer Gutiérrez	Council Member	2
149	00:57:48	00:58:16	28	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
150	00:58:17	00:58:32	15	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
151	00:58:33	00:58:44	12	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
152	00:58:45	00:58:57	12	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
153	00:59:00	00:59:23	22	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
154	00:59:25	00:59:33	9	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
155	00:59:34	01:00:27	52	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
156	01:00:28	01:00:36	8	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
157	01:00:37	01:00:45	8	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
158	01:00:45	01:00:58	13	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
159	01:00:59	01:01:13	14	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
160	01:01:14	01:01:26	11	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
161	01:01:26	01:01:45	19	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
162	01:01:46	01:02:02	16	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
163	01:02:03	01:02:05	2	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
164	01:02:06	01:02:29	23	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
165	01:02:30	01:02:52	21	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
166	01:02:53	01:02:59	5	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
167	01:03:01	01:03:43	42	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
168	01:03:44	01:04:09	25	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
169	01:04:10	01:04:30	20	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
170	01:04:30	01:04:44	14	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
171	01:04:45	01:05:16	31	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
172	01:05:17	01:06:00	42	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
173	01:06:01	01:06:11	10	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
174	01:06:11	01:06:23	12	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	2
175	01:06:24	01:06:39	14	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
176	01:06:39	01:06:47	8	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
177	01:06:48	01:07:05	17	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
178	01:07:05	01:07:21	15	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
179	01:07:23	01:07:45	23	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
180	01:07:45	01:07:49	4	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
181	01:07:50	01:08:11	21	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
182	01:08:15	01:09:30	75	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
183	01:09:32	01:09:33	1	Gabriela Castillo Madrid	Witness — SpaceXAI	2
184	01:09:34	01:09:35	1	Julie Menin	Speaker	2
185	01:09:36	01:09:51	15	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	3
186	01:09:52	01:10:19	28	Julie Menin	Speaker	3
187	01:10:24	01:12:24	120	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
188	01:12:26	01:12:31	6	Julie Menin	Speaker	3
189	01:12:33	01:18:39	366	Qiaojing Ella Zheng	Witness — counsel to Devin Kim	3
190	01:18:39	01:18:41	2	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	3
191	01:18:41	01:19:10	29	Qiaojing Ella Zheng	Witness — counsel to Devin Kim	3
192	01:19:10	01:20:38	88	Julie Menin	Speaker	3
193	01:20:42	01:20:48	6	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
194	01:20:49	01:21:01	12	Julie Menin	Speaker	3
195	01:21:04	01:21:13	9	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
196	01:21:13	01:21:29	16	Julie Menin	Speaker	3
197	01:21:31	01:22:11	40	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
198	01:22:11	01:22:28	16	Julie Menin	Speaker	3
199	01:22:32	01:22:41	9	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
200	01:22:43	01:22:56	13	Julie Menin	Speaker	3
201	01:22:59	01:24:17	78	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
202	01:24:18	01:24:47	30	Julie Menin	Speaker	3
203	01:24:48	01:24:54	6	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
204	01:24:55	01:25:10	15	Julie Menin	Speaker	3
205	01:25:13	01:26:42	89	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
206	01:26:42	01:26:57	15	Julie Menin	Speaker	3
207	01:27:00	01:27:19	20	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
208	01:27:20	01:27:42	22	Julie Menin	Speaker	3
209	01:27:45	01:28:35	50	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
210	01:28:36	01:28:48	13	Julie Menin	Speaker	3
211	01:28:51	01:28:52	1	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
212	01:28:53	01:29:49	56	Julie Menin	Speaker	3
213	01:29:51	01:30:10	19	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
214	01:30:10	01:30:57	47	Julie Menin	Speaker	3
215	01:30:58	01:31:35	38	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	3
216	01:31:38	01:33:34	116	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
217	01:33:35	01:33:50	15	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	3
218	01:33:53	01:33:55	2	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
219	01:33:55	01:34:12	16	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	3
220	01:34:16	01:34:23	7	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
221	01:34:24	01:35:22	58	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	3
222	01:35:26	01:35:58	32	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
223	01:35:59	01:36:23	24	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	3
224	01:36:26	01:36:34	8	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
225	01:36:34	01:37:02	28	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	3
226	01:37:02	01:37:03	1	Devin Kim	Witness — former xAI employee	3
227	01:37:04	01:37:04	0	Qiaojing Ella Zheng	Witness — counsel to Devin Kim	3
228	01:37:05	01:38:28	83	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	4
229	01:38:53	01:38:55	1	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	4
230	01:39:00	01:41:41	161	Bryce Rogers	Witness — RAD Collective	4
231	01:41:45	01:44:10	146	Megan Lagerquist	Witness — RAD Collective	4
232	01:44:14	01:46:17	123	Kalima [surname unknown]	Witness — Demilitarize Brooklyn Navy Yard	4
233	01:46:18	01:46:19	1	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	4
234	01:46:32	01:48:25	113	Steve Kramer	Witness — Get Out the Vote	4
235	01:48:26	01:48:33	8	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	4
236	01:48:44	01:48:46	2	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	5
237	01:48:59	01:50:03	64	Sophie Cote	Witness — public	5
238	01:50:04	01:50:09	4	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	5
239	01:50:16	01:52:19	123	Ajeet Singh	Witness — public	5
240	01:52:19	01:52:21	2	Sergeant-at-Arms	Sergeant-at-Arms	5
241	01:52:22	01:52:24	2	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	5
242	01:52:24	01:52:40	16	Ajeet Singh	Witness — public	5
243	01:52:41	01:52:45	4	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	5
244	01:52:48	01:54:27	99	Chowdhury Hasan Mahmud	Witness — public	5
245	01:54:28	01:54:45	17	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	5
246	01:54:53	01:56:58	125	Julie Menin	Speaker	6
247	01:56:58	01:57:20	21	Carmen De La Rosa	Council Member	6

How this was made

Speaker turns come from the Deepgram transcript, merged by voice and gap as described in the repository README; the parts of the hearing and who sat on each are in panels.json. Times are seconds from the start of the Council's recording, not the clock time of the hearing.

Speaker names come from self-introductions, the chair calling on people, and voice clusters. Names were assigned by AI agents working from these sources, at BetaNYC's direction. Elected officials were checked against Legistar and NYS Open Legislation. Other names were not individually verified by a person.

Talk time is approximate. 56 of the 248 turns hold two speakers: a question and the start of its answer, for example, where the diarization did not split them. Those turns count toward the person named on the turn.

Built by scripts/build_panels.py from panels.json, transcript/turns.csv and speakers.csv. This is a machine transcript, not an official record; check the video before quoting anyone.